|
|
又一轮中国工程院院士评选开始了，不知道又有几多高官和不学无术或混混教授入选其中。所幸的是，毕竟时代不同于以往，今天再要靠用专业的东西蒙骗外行，已经没有以前那么容易了。但是，仍然有很多所谓的大学和大学教授希冀用这一招来蒙骗广大无辜的观众-在大众的眼里，加工过的量化的指标比真正的学术水准和圈内的评价重要。中南大学的最近作为和工程院院士提名人又一次希望大众成为盲目的跟随者，希望大众为他们广含水分的量化指标所迷惑。
最近比较关注中南大学，一方面因为它拿了个国家科技发明一等奖（虽然有很大的争议），另外是今年的两院院士增选它提名了三个人。湖南的大学有这么大的成就，还是要高兴一下。报着这样的饿目的，我饶有兴趣地查了它的三个提名人的学术记录。结果却令人大跌眼镜-就这样的水平，竟然还敢去参与院士评选。考虑到这次中南提名的人物都是中南研究顶级的人选，这次检索的结果只带来了两方面深深的担忧-中国的院士水平太次或者中南真正的科研水平太次。我个人倾向于选择后者，因为很多的院士的学术记录表现还是不错的。
先看看中南大学的副校长邱冠周的学术记录，作为这次的国家科技发明一等奖的主要参与人之一和中南大学的副校长，邱先生应该是著作等身，学术成果昂然吧。作为工科的教授，即使SCI的记录不怎么样，EI应该有良好的表现吧。可惜到EI上一搜，真是令人大失所望。下面是邱副校长的EI记录：
Search Results
42 records found in Compendex, Inspec & NTIS for: (((Qiu,Guanzhou) WN All fields) AND ((Central South Univ) WN AF)), 1969-2005 Save Search | Create Alert
Compendex : 38 Results Inspec : 4 Results NTIS : 0 Results Compendex, Inspec & NTIS : 42 Results
Sort by: Relevance Date Author
Remove duplicate records from the first 500 results from: Compendex Inspec
1. Ultrafine milling for the processing of gold-bearing sulphides
Yang, Huaming (Dept. of Mineral Eng., Central South Univ.); Hu, Yuehua; Ao, Weiqin; Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo Source: Rare Metals, v 21, n 2, June, 2002, p 133-136
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
2. Density functional calculation of electronic structure and optical properties of FeS/sub 2/ (pyrite)
Xiao Qi (Dept. of Miner. Process., Central South Univ., Changsha, China); Qiu Guanzhou; Qin Wenqing; Wang Dianzou Source: Acta Optica Sinica, v 22, n 12, Dec. 2002, p 1501-6 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract | Detailed Record
3. Chemical synthesis of nanocrystalline ZrO2-SnO2 composite powders
Yang, Huaming (Dept. of Inorganic Mat., Sch. of Resources Proc., Central South Univ.); Zhang, Xiangchao; Yang, Wuguo; Huang, Chenghuan; Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Rare Metals, v 23, n 2, June, 2004, p 182-184
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
4. Affecting mechanism of grinding aid during ultrafine grinding
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ); Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 31, n 5, Oct, 2000, p 400-402 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
5. Structural changes of talc powder during ultrafine grinding
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo Source: Kuei Suan Jen Hsueh Pao/ Journal of the Chinese Ceramic Society, v 27, n 5, Oct, 1999, p 580-584 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
6. Study on the technology of producing strontium ferrite from magnetite concentrate
Xiao, Qi (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Jinshu Kuangshan/Metal Mine, n 1, Jan 15, 2000, p 54-55 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
7. Iron behaviour in growth of thiobacillus ferrooxidans
Qiu, Guanzhou (Central South Univ of Technology); Liu, Jianshe; Wang, Dianzuo; Xu, Jing Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 29, n 3, 1998, p 226-228 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
8. Effect of CaCl2 on sinter RDI
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Tang, Aidong Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 29, n 3, 1998, p 229-232 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
9. Mechano-chemical change of powder in super-fine comminution
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo Source: Jinshu Kuangshan/Metal Mine, n 11, Nov 15, 2000, p 24-26, 31 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
10. New technique of superpure iron powder using coal-based direct reduction
Zhang, Qingcen (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Li, Quiqi; Xiao, Qi Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 29, n 1, 1998, p 18-21 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
11. Catalyzing the direct reduction of cold-bound pellets from titanomagnetite concentrate
Zhu, Deqing (Central South Univ of Technology); Guo, Yufeng; Qiu, Guanzhou; Jiang, Tao Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 31, n 3, Jun, 2000, p 208-211 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
12. Simultaneous leaching of Mn-containing silver ore and as-containing gold ore
Yuan, Mingliang (Central South Univ of Technology); Chen, Ke; Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Huagong Yejin/Engineering Chemistry & Metallurgy, v 21, n 2, Apr, 2000, p 179-182 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
13. Molecular structure mould and selecting criterion of organic binder for iron ore pellet
Li, Hongxu (Central South Univ of Technology); Jiang, Tao; Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 31, n 1, Feb, 2000, p 17-20 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
14. Thermal hardening of acid titanium-bearing pellets to prolong campaign life of blast furnace
Zhu, Deqing (Central South Univ); Pan, Runrun; Jiang, Tao; Guo, Yufeng; Yang, Yongbin; Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 31, n 6, Dec, 2000, p 489-492 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
15. Study on the new technology of the mechanical and chemical modification of mineral surface
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ); Wang, Dianzuo; Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Jinshu Kuangshan/Metal Mine, n 7, Jul 15, 2000, p 13-16, 28 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
16. Studies on improving the quality of pelletization of high-sulphur magnetite concentrate
Guo, Yufeng (Central South Univ of Technology); Jiang, Tao; Fu, Shoucheng; Qiu, Guanzhou; Cai, Ruzhuo Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 29, n 2, 1998, p 127-130 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
17. Reduction of cold bond pellets of magnetite concentrate in weak reductive atmosphere at low temperature
Zhou, Hong (Central South Univ of Technology); Chen, Qiyuan; Zhang, Pingmin; Qiu, Guanzhou; Jiang, Tao Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 29, n 1, 1998, p 25-27 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
18. Effect of coal-kind on coal-based direct reduction of low grade iron ore
Zhang, Qingcen (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Xiao, Qi Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 28, n 2, Apr, 1997, p 126-129 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
19. Study on the removing of MgSO4 from MnSO4 solution based on the aqueous system phase diagram
Yuan, Mingliang (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 31, n 3, Jun, 2000, p 212-214 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
20. Study on ESR spectrum of coal
Qiu, Guanzhou (Central South Univ of Technology); Liu, Guogen; Hu, Shanting; Hu, Yuehua Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 28, n 5, 1997, p 427-429 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
21. Study and application of polarographic wave of molybdenum-morin complex
Liu, Guogen (Central South Univ of Technology); Huang, Songxian; Qiu, Guanzhou; Hu, Yuehua Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 26, n 5, Oct, 1995, p 688-692 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
22. Researches on the influence of additives on the coal-base direct reduction of high-iron-content red mud
Qiu, Guanzhou (Central South Univ of Technology); Liu, Yongkang; Mei, Xiangong Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 26, n 6, Dec, 1995, p 734-738 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
23. Method of wastewater treatment from nickel metallurgy
Liu, Jianshe (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Shu, Yude; Wang, Dianzuo Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 28, n 4, 1997, p 333-335 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
24. Investigation on mechanical-chemistry modification with stirred mill
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 28, n 6, 1997, p 536-538 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
25. Technique and theory of two ore method to leach manganese dioxide ore
Yuan, Mingliang (Central South Univ of Technology); Mei, Xiangong; Chen, Jin; Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 28, n 4, 1997, p 329-332 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
26. Behaviour of iron oxide in the direct reduction of goosan type-gold composite ores with coal base
Mei, Xiangong (Central South Univ of Technology); Yuan, Mingliang; Qiu, Guanzhou; Chen, Jin Source: Zhongnan Gongye Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Central South University of Technology, v 28, n 6, 1997, p 533-535 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
27. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation by using artificial neural network of pattern recognition-bond parameters
Wang, Xueye (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo; Chen, Nianyi Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 1, 1998, p 142-148
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
28. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters. 3. Estimation of liquidus temperature and expert system
Wang Xueye (Dept. of Mineral Eng., Central South Univ. of Technol., Changsha, China;); Qiu Guanzhou; Wang Dianzuo; Li Chonge; Chen Nianyi Source: Transactions of the Nonferrous Metals Society of China, v 8, n 3, Sept. 1998, p 505-9
Database: Inspec
Abstract | Detailed Record
29. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters
Wang Xueye (Dept. of Miner. Eng., Central South Univ. of Technol., Changsha, China;); Qiu Guanzhou; Wang Dianzuo; Chen Nianyi Source: Transactions of the Nonferrous Metals Society of China, v 8, n 1, March 1998, p 142-8
Database: Inspec
Abstract | Detailed Record
30. Fabrication and industrial application of ferromanganese composite briquette
Yang, Huaming (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou Source: Journal of Central South University of Technology (English Edition), v 5, n 1, May, 1998, p 7-10
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
31. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters. 2. Prediction of phase diagrams of ternary molten salt systems
Qiu Guanzhou (Dept. of Mineral Eng., Central South Univ. of Technol., Changsha, China;); Wang Xueye; Wang Dianzuo; Chen Nianyi Source: Transactions of the Nonferrous Metals Society of China, v 8, n 2, June 1998, p 313-18
Database: Inspec
Abstract | Detailed Record
32. Molten salt phase diagram calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition bond parameters Part 3. Estimation of liquidus temperature and expert system
Wang, Xueye (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo; Li, Chonghe; Chen, Nianyi Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 3, 1998, p 505-509
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
33. Expert system for retrieval and prediction of properties in some phase diagrams of molten salt systems
Wang, Xueye (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo; Li, Chonghe; Chen, Nianyi Source: Zhongguo Youse Jinshu Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Nonferrous Metals, v 8, n 2, Jun, 1998, p 295-298 Language: Chinese, English
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
34. Galvanic interaction of contacting sulfide particle and its effect on flotation
Qin, Wenqing (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Xu, Jing; Hu, Yuehua Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 4, 1998, p 661-665
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
35. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters Part 2. Prediction of phase diagrams of ternary molten salt systems
Qiu, Guanzhou (Central South Univ of Technology); Wang, Xueye; Wang, Dianzuo; Chen, Nianyi Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 2, 1998, p 313-318
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
36. Isothermal kinetics of the first stage reduction of magnetite cold bond pellets with carbon monoxide
Chen, Qiyuan (Central South Univ of Technology); Zhou, Hong; Zhang, Pingmin; Qiu, Guanzhou; Xu, Jing Source: Journal of Central South University of Technology (English Edition), v 5, n 1, May, 1998, p 1-3
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
37. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters. Part 3. Estimation of liquidus temperature and expert system
Wang, Xueye (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo; Li, Chonghe; Chen, Nianyi Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 3, Sep, 1998, p 505-509
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
38. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters. Part 1. The prediction of the phase diagrams of binary molten salt systems
Wang, Xueye (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Wang, Dianzuo; Chen, Nianyi Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 1, Mar, 1998, p 142-148
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
39. Molten salt phase diagrams calculation using artificial neural network or pattern recognition-bond parameters
Qiu, Guanzhou (Central South Univ of Technology); Wang, Xueye; Wang, Dianzuo; Chen, Nianyi Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 8, n 2, Jun, 1998, p 313-318
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
40. Influence of additives on slag-iron separation during direct reduction of coal-base high-iron-content red mud
Qiu, Guanzhou (Central South Univ of Technology); Liu, Yongkang; Jiang, Tao; Hu, Yuehua; Mei, Xiangong Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 6, n 2, June, 1996, p 1-7
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
41. Carrier flotation of ultrafine particle wolframite
Hu, Yuehua (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Luo, Lin; Xu, Jin; Wang, Dianzuo Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 4, n 4, Dec, 1994, p 10-15
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
42. Flotation classification approach by controlling interactions between particles
Luo, Lin (Central South Univ of Technology); Qiu, Guanzhou; Hu, Yuehua; Wang, Dianzuo; He, Boquan Source: Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China (English Edition), v 5, n 4, Dec, 1995, p 58-63
Database: Compendex
Abstract | Detailed Record
随便看看，便可发现中南大学副校长，工程院院士提名人，中南大学科研的领军人物邱教授的发表的论文的特点。这里暂且总结几点，有兴趣的欢迎继续：
1.文章绝大部分发表在两种杂志上:<中南工业大学学报>和<中国有色金属学报>.这两种杂志在被EI收录的数千种期刊里是什么档次和水平，相信大家都清楚；
2.通讯作者的文章极少，仅仅5篇（其他的感兴趣的可以再查查）；
3.从摘要看来，绝大多数文章没有什么创见，基本上是国内一般般大学的研究生期末论文水平。
这样的结果真的令人失望，如果中南就靠这样的人领军科研，后果将不堪设想。但是，这样的人偏偏是中南的科研领军人物，我们有充分的理由怀疑中南大学真正的科研水平，因为金属冶金是中南最好的学科。最好的学科尚且是这样的样子，其他不厉害的学科不知道怎么一个差字了得。
我本来还打算继续搜索一下邱教授的SCI和ISTP记录的，但是估计也好不到哪里去。有兴趣的可以继续搜索下，还有其他几位候选人的记录。但是我担心，恐怕也就那水平，如果EI，SCI等真的能说明些问题的话。
这也算是给本来一般般，却硬要吹那么大牛皮的中南大学一点教训吧。希望中南再也不要随便去蒙骗大众了-越来越多的大众知道什么是学术的，什么是非学术的，什么是高水平的，什么是混混类的。 |
|
/1 
IP卡
狗仔卡
发表于 2005-7-6 19:14:49
提升卡
置顶卡
沉默卡
喧嚣卡
变色卡
显身卡
楼主