从中南大学工程院院士提名人邱冠周看中南大学真正的学术水平

qczd

不知道楼主是不是理科的
太注重论文啦。
如果完全以论文作为评价标准
袁隆平也当不了院士。

ecouter

楼主估计是学理科的
对于自己不熟悉的专业，还是不要说的如此理直气壮的好，不然搞不好要闹笑话

讨厌吹牛

下面是引用ecouter于2005-07-07 22:12发表的:
楼主估计是学理科的
对于自己不熟悉的专业，还是不要说的如此理直气壮的好，不然搞不好要闹笑话

谢谢楼上的善意的意见。
  在研究的层次，虽然专业不同，但是研究的道路和基本的方法论是相通的。比如说，有人认为《中南工业大学学报》（自然科学版）和《中国有色金属学报》是好杂志，就是井底观天的看法了。学术界评价一本杂志的档次高低常用的指标是引用点数“citation index”。SCI和EI的检索都有查询引用点数的工具，目的也就是为了让别人鉴别什么杂志真正是上档次的。不过可惜的是，大部分的中南的人士（很多的是研究生）连这个都弄 不清楚，就有点叫人可惜（我同时也很奇怪，到处说自己很厉害的中南大学居然连SCI检索工具都没有！）
  这篇文章不是原创，从文章可以看出，原作者跟中南的邱教授也没有私人的恩怨。这篇文章纯粹是为了让大家了解中南大学的科研到底是什么水平。中南大学最近以来，到处吹嘘，让大家知道它的真正的底细也是好的。至少可以让中南大学的老师和学生认清楚自己，不要再混淆视听。
  另外，听说邱教授同时还是973的什么首席科学家。如果真的是这样，这篇文章就更有功绩了。让大家更清楚地知道大学学术资源的分配是多么的不公-学术水平比较平平的人往往占有众多的学术资源。这里引起的问题，就不是中揭露一个不合格的院士候选人那么简单了-它会更有意义。
  还有一点，工程领域的不要发文章。我并不见得。如果有很好的原创性成果和技术创新，为什么不发文章。关键是文章发不到很好的杂志上去。其中根本的原因就是没有什么创新点。邱教授的文章绝大多数属于这种类型的。
  附带说一句可能令中南大学的人士丧气的话，在中南号称很厉害的材料领域，我检索了几个主要的学科带头人近年来的学术记录，没有一篇是发表在比较好的学术期刊上的。而比较低调的湖大，据我所知，唐元洪教授就有一篇文章被象Advanced Material这样的比较高级别的杂志接受。（我其实对中南大学所宣称的厉害的材料科学研究一直是持怀疑态度的。从他们教授们平平的学术记录看来，我的怀疑是很有根据的）。
  关于工科的教授要不要发文章的问题，我在这不想多说什么。下面是随便检索到的湖大电气院王耀男教授的EI记录（湖大的同学可以通过校园网检索王教授的SCI记录）。值得注意的是，王老师即不是什么973首席科学家，也不是什么院士候选人，所拥有的学术资源也远远没有邱教授多。但是王教授的学术记录要远远好过中南的院士候选人邱教授。这里有很多很懂行的朋友可以比较比较看。
Search Results
42 records found in Compendex, Inspec & NTIS for: (((Wang,Yaonan) WN All fields) AND ((Hunan Univ) WN AF)), 1969-2005     Save Search  |  Create Alert
Compendex : 18 Results  Inspec : 24 Results  NTIS : 0 Results  Compendex, Inspec & NTIS : 42 Results  

Sort by:    Relevance   Date   Author

Remove duplicate records from the first 500 results from:  Compendex    Inspec     


1.  Fuzzy-based power factor control for brushless doubly-fed machines
Huang Shoudao (Coll. of Electr. & Informational Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wei Yan; Lin Youjie; Wang Yaonan Source: Proceedings of the 4th World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation (Cat. No.02EX527), 2002, pt. 1, p 587-91 vol.1
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


2.  Investigation of a power flow controller of SSSC based on self-tuning PI controller with fuzzy logic
Wang, Hui (Hunan Univ.); Wang, Yaonan; Xu, Weidong Source: Diangong Jishu Xuebao/Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, v 19, n 7, July, 2004, p 65-69 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


3.  Study of eliminating harmonic currents for multi-function balance transformer and its filter
Zhang, Zhiwen (Hunan Univ.); Wang, Yaonan; Tang, Qiu; Xiong, Zhiyao; Zhou, Lawu; Liu, Fusheng Source: Diangong Jishu Xuebao/Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, v 19, n 3, March, 2004, p 25-30 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


4.  Research on an instrument for the measurement of fouling in condenser
Fan, Shao-Sheng (Coll. of Elec. and Info. Eng., Hunan Univ.); Wang, Yaonan Source: Hunan Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Hunan University Natural Sciences, v 32, n 2, April, 2005, p 33-37 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


5.  Robust adaptive dynamical neural control for uncertain chaotic system
Tan, Wen (Sch. of Info./Electrical Engineering, HuNan Univ. of Sci. and Technology); Wang, Yaonan; Zhou, Shaowu; Liu, Zurun Source: Proceedings of the World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation (WCICA), v 2, WCICA 2004 - Fifth World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation, Conference Proceedings, 2004, p 1300-1303
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


6.  Realization of high precision bandgap reference
Jiang, Jinguang (Coll. of Elec. and Info. Eng., Hunan Univ.); Wang, Yaonan Source: Pan Tao Ti Hsueh Pao/Chinese Journal of Semiconductors, v 25, n 7, July, 2004, p 852-857 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


7.  Speed sensorless vector control of induction motor based on the MRAS theory
Wang Yaonan (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., China); Lu Jiantao; Huang Shoudao; Qiu Sihai Source: Conference Proceedings IPEMC 2004. The 4th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (IEEE Cat. No.04EX677), 2004, pt. 2, p 645-8 Vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


8.  Active and reactive power control for brushless doubly-fed machine
Huang Shoudao (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., China); Wang Yi; Wang Yaonan; Ren Guangfa Source: Conference Proceedings IPEMC 2004. The 4th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (IEEE Cat. No.04EX677), 2004, pt. 2, p 640-4 Vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


9.  The investigation of PWM rectifier control method
Wang Hui (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., China); Chen Jihua; Huang Shoudao; Wang Yaonan Source: Conference Proceedings IPEMC 2004. The 4th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (IEEE Cat. No.04EX677), 2004, pt. 2, p 673-5 Vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


10.  Objective evaluation and analysis of multisensor image fusion
Li Shutao (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan; Zhang Changfan Source: Chinese Journal of Scientific Instrument, v 23, n 6, Dec. 2002, p 651-4 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


11.  A novel method of pose and motion estimation based on vision and extended Kalman filter
Wu Xuedong (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan Source: Chinese Journal of Scientific Instrument, v 25, n 5, Oct. 2004, p 676-80, 687 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


12.  A image classifier based on fuzzy wavelet basis function neural network
Mao Jianxu (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan; Sun Wei Source: Chinese Journal of Scientific Instrument, v 24, n 2, April 2003, p 114-18 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


13.  Fuzzy model predictive control for active power filter
Fan Shaosheng (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan Source: 2004 IEEE International Conference on Electric Utility Deregulation, Restructuring and Power Technologies. Proceedings (IEEE Cat. No.04EX777), 2004, pt. 1, p 295-300 Vol.1
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


14.  Intelligent adaptive PID controller design for static var compensator
Peng, Jianchun (Hunan Univ); Huang, Chun; Wang, Yaonan Source: Hunan Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Hunan University Natural Sciences, v 26, n 5, Oct, 1999, p 50-55 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


15.  Intelligent co-ordinate control for DC drive system
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ); Tong, Tiaosheng Source: Diangong Jishu Xuebao/Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, v 13, n 1, 1998, p 1-6 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


16.  Genetic-based neurofuzzy control for complex industrial process
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ); Zhang, Changfan Source: Kongzhi Lilun Yu Yinyong/Control Theory and Applications, v 16, n 6, Dec, 1999, p 886-891
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


17.  Automatic classification of remote sensing image using neural network
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ) Source: Hunan Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Hunan University Natural Sciences, v 25, n 4, 1998, p 61-66 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


18.  New tendency of intelligent analogue neural network development
Yu, Qunming (Hunan Univ); Wang, Yaonan Source: Moshi Shibie yu Rengong Zhineng/Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, v 12, n 3, Sep, 1999, p 313-319 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


19.  Real-time supervision and management system for industrial production process based on C/S structure
Zhang, Jing (Hunan Univ); Zhang, Xiaogang; Wang, Yaonan; Li, Jinsong Source: Hunan Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Hunan University Natural Sciences, v 27, n 3, Jun, 2000, p 57-62 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


20.  Fast learning algorithm for neural networks and its application in image edge detector
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ) Source: Jisuanji Yanjiu yu Fazhan/Computer Research and Development, v 34, n 5, May, 1997, p 377-381 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


21.  Hybrid intelligent control for industrial rotary kiln plant
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ) Source: Kong Zhi Li Lun Yu Ying Yong/Control Theory and Applications, v 13, n 6, Dec, 1996, p 770-777
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


22.  A supervisory control system including digital simulation realized by PLC
Duan Feng (Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Guo Ping; Duan Wei; Duan Zhenghua; Wang Yaonan Source: Proceedings of the 3rd World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation (Cat. No.00EX393), 2000, pt. 5, p 3721-3 vol.5 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


23.  An adaptive fuzzy control for AC servo system
Sun Wei (Coll. of Electr. & Informational Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan Source: ICEMS'2001. Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Electrical Machines and Systems (IEEE Cat. No.01EX501), 2001, pt. 2, p 782-6 vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


24.  Study on a new method for fuzzy logic controller design
Peng Jianchun (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Jiang Hui; Wang Yaonan Source: Advances in Modelling & Analysis B: Signals, Information, Patterns, Data Acquisition, Transmission, Processing, Classification, v 42, n 1, 1999, p 21-31
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


25.  Genetic based neuro-fuzzy control for complex industrial process
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Zhang Changfan Source: Control Theory & Applications, v 16, n 6, Dec. 1999, p 886-91
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  

26.  The segmentation of kiln flame image based on neural networks
Li Shutao (Coll. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China;); Wang Yaonan Source: Chinese Journal of Scientific Instrument, v 22, n 1, Feb. 2001, p 10-12, 16 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


27.  Self-learning control using Gaussian potential function neural networks and its application
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Peng Jianchun; Wang Hui Source: Control Theory & Applications, v 15, n 5, Oct. 1998, p 701-7 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


28.  Fuzzy filter based on neural network and its application to image restoration
Li Shutao (Inst. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan; Zhang Changfan; Mao Jianxu Source: WCC 2000 - ICSP 2000. 2000 5th International Conference on Signal Processing Proceedings. 16th World Computer Congress 2000, 2000, pt. 2, p 1133-8 vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


29.  A new fuzzy logic controller and its application [in power systems]
Peng Jianchun (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China;); Huang Chun; Wang Yaonan; Fu Weisheng; Li Xiangqi; Huang Lianggang Source: POWERCON '98. 1998 International Conference on Power System Technology. Proceedings (Cat. No.98EX151), 1998, pt. 2, p 809-13 vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


30.  Study on a new method for fuzzy logic controller design
Peng, Jianchun (Hunan Univ); Jiang, Hui; Wang, Yaonan Source: Advances in Modeling and Analysis B, v 42, n 1, 1999, p 1.21-1.31
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


31.  Intelligent controller using fuzzy neural networks and its application
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ) Source: Tien Tzu Hsueh Pao/Acta Electronica Sinica, v 24, n 8, Aug, 1996, p 105-107 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


32.  ANN based load-frequency internal model control of multi-area power systems
Peng Jianchun (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Huang Chun; Wang Yaonan Source: Advances in Modelling & Analysis B: Signals, Information, Patterns, Data Acquisition, Transmission, Processing, Classification, v 41, n 1, 1999, p 51-60
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


33.  An intelligent control using fuzzy sliding neural network and its application
Zhang Changfan (Dept. of Electr. & Inf. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Wang Yaonan Source: Fifth International Conference for Young Computer Scientists. ICYCS'99. Advances in Computer Science and Technology, 1999, pt. 2, p 1061 vol.2
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


34.  ANN based load-frequency internal model control of multi-area power systems
Peng, Jianchun (Hunan Univ); Huang, Chun; Wang, Yaonan Source: Advances in Modeling and Analysis B, v 41, n 1-2, 1999, p 1.51-1.60
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


35.  An intelligent controller using fuzzy neural networks and its application
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China) Source: Acta Electronica Sinica, v 24, n 8, Aug. 1996, p 105-7 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


36.  Application of artificial neural networks in servo optimal robust control
Wang, Yaonan (Hunan Univ) Source: Kongzhi yu Juece/Control and Decision, v 12, n 1, Jan, 1997, 7pp Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


37.  A parallel algorithm for neural networks and application in remote sensing classifying
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China); Song Ming Source: Acta Electronica Sinica, v 25, n 10, Oct. 1997, p 99-101 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


38.  Genetic-based fuzzy net control and its application
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China) Source: High Technology Letters, v 7, n 3, March 1997, p 25-8 Language: Chinese
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


39.  A hybrid intelligent control for industrial rotary kiln plant
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China) Source: Control Theory & Applications, v 13, n 6, Dec. 1996, p 770-7
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


40.  A neural fuzzy logic self-organizing controller for nonlinear system control
Wang Yaonan (Dept. of Electron. Eng., Hunan Univ., Changsha, China) Source: Control Theory & Applications, v 14, n 5, Oct. 1997, p 748-53
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


41.  The design and application of expert intelligent fuzzy control system (EIFCS)
Zhang Jing (Dept. of Electr. Eng., Hunan Univ., Hanan, China); Wang Yaonan; Tong Tiaosheng; Zhang Xianniing Source: ICARCV '92. Second International Conference on Automation, Robotics and Computer Vision, 1992, p A1-1.6/1-5 vol.3
Database: Inspec
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


42.  Scheme of intelligent control applied to a servo system
Chen, Kang (Hunan Univ); Wang, Yaonan; Xiong, Qiusi Source: IECON Proceedings (Industrial Electronics Conference), v 3, 1996, p 1735-1739
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record

lixunghuan

我是中南学材料的,不过上面的帖子根本看不懂
看来我们学生更没水平
严重请求楼主去我们中南当校长

qczd

讨厌吹牛
原文发在什么地方
请给个链结

qczd

另，你能不能发一下今年推选为后选院士的湖大土木院及汽机院两个陈教授的EI记录，我和电气院王教授的比较一下。谢谢
邱冠周进入了第二轮，你怎么看呢？说明后选人都不行，还是评选机构被中南收买了？

qczd

邱冠周这么水的人，能被中南大学提名为院士后选人，说明中南大学实在没人才了
于是得出了“中南大学真正的学术水平”差劲的结论
但是他偏偏又进入了第二轮，望讨厌吹牛解释一下，这又能得出什么结论。

袁隆平没啥文章也能当院士，我们是不是该愤慨院士评选制度的不公

qczd

查了一下钟志华教授的EI  Compendex 也不怎么样。不能说他水平不行 而是有些领域要发好文章 实在很难的。在工程学科 只要能解决实际难题，就很不错了。中国的工科水平本来就距离世界强国很远。
Search Results
10 records found in Compendex for: (((zhong,zhihua) WN AU) AND ((Hunan Univ) WN AF)), 1969-2005     Save Search  |  Create Alert
Sort by:    Relevance   Date   Author   Source   Publisher


1.  Modeling of occupant dynamic response to car-barriers crash on highway
Huang, Hongwu (Coll. of Mech. and Automotive Eng., Hunan Univ.); Yang, Jikuang; Liu, Zhengheng; Zhong, Zhihua Source: Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering (English Edition), v 17, n 2, June, 2004, p 276-279
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


2.  Parallel explicit finite element simulation of vehicle collisions
Cao, Yinfeng (Lab. of Vehicle Body Design, Hunan Univ.); Li, Guangyao; Zhong, Zhihua Source: Jixie Gongcheng Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, v 41, n 2, February, 2005, p 153-157 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


3.  Exact optimum blank design using the wire mapping method based on the FEM results
Zhou, Jun (Hunan Univ.); Ma, Chuang; Li, Guangyao; Zhong, Zhihua Source: Jixie Gongcheng Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, v 38, n 12, December, 2002, p 103-106+110 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


4.  Research on new rapid manufacturing technique of raw moulds for large-sized sheet metal forming
Yang, Yanping (Hunan Univ.); Huang, Zhi; Zhong, Zhihua; Mo, Xuhui Source: Jixie Gongcheng Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, v 40, n 1, January, 2004, p 160-164 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


5.  Crashworthiness improvement of passenger cars with computer simulation techniques
Zhang, Weigang (Hunan Univ.); Zhong, Zhihua; Zhao, Youping; Gu, Li; Liu, Yongchao Source: Jixie Gongcheng Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, v 38, n 3, March, 2002, p 135-138 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


6.  Accurate upper bound solutions for several typical plastic forming problems
Chen, Fangzu (Hunan Univ.); Li, Guangyao; Zhong, Zhihua Source: Jixie Gongcheng Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, v 39, n 6, June, 2003, p 4-8 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


7.  Computer simulation of airbag unfolding process
Zhong, Zhihua (Hunan Univ) Source: Qiche Gongcheng/Automotive Engineering, v 22, n 5, 2000, p 303-305, 312 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


8.  Weighted optimization design of the front part of passenger car in consideration of longitudinal crash characteristics
Lei, Zhengbao (Hunan Univ); Zhong, Zhihua Source: Journal of Vibration and Shock, v 17, n 4, Dec, 1998, p 49-52 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


9.  Review of the research on computer simulation of working process of automobile airbag in China and abroad
You, Shihui (Hunan Univ); Zhong, Zhihua Source: Hunan Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Hunan University Natural Sciences, v 27, n 3, Jun, 2000, p 43-48, 53 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record  


10.  New methods for frictional contact in simulation of sheet metal forming
Zhong, Zhihua (Hunan Univ); Li, Guangyao Source: Jixie Gongcheng Xuebao/Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, v 37, n 2, Feb, 2001, p 33-37 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record

qczd

陈政清教授的EI Compendex
用Hunan Univ查询为零 用Central South Univ 查 有一篇
Search Results
1 record found in Compendex for: (((chen,zhengqing) WN AU) AND ((Central South Univ) WN AF)), 1969-2005     Save Search  |  Create Alert
Sort by:    Relevance   Date   Author   Source   Publisher


1.  Application of EMD (empirical mode decomposition) method to eliminate local stronger disturbance from vibration signal of a bridge
Wang, Xuemin (Sch. of Civil Eng. and Architecture, Central South Univ.); Huang, Fanglin; Chen, Zhengqing Source: Jixie Qiandu/Journal of Mechanical Strength, v 27, n 1, February, 2005, p 33-37 Language: Chinese
Database: Compendex
Abstract  |  Detailed Record

qczd

费这么多事查这些东西 并不是对两位教授有过节，我也不认识他们。当然也不是为了说明湖南大学推选他们出来就说明湖南大学水平怎么样。据我所知 这两位教授是挺厉害的。
我要表达的意思是，工科和理科不一样的 判断一个人的学术成就不光是看论文，而要看他对我国在这方面的水平提高做了多大的贡献。如果非要把他们拿国际上去比 一定要他们做出在国际上有突破性的东西，我觉得太强人所难。

呵呵，我觉得楼主一定在学术上还是很有成就的。我就不行啦，就想赶快混个毕业赚钱去/ 连查个EI都摸索了半天 也许有些文章没查到，见谅。在今天以前，我还从没去查过EI的文章呢（开学研二） 平时看文章就在cnki的中国学术期刊网看看。你可能要说我这个中南大学的学生水平差， 连EI都没查过，但我想说，人和人不一样的，选择的道路也不同。
好了，睡觉。

庄用灌水

挖哈哈，请转笑话幽默版

化学所

呵呵，楼上的 中南大学的 那位研究生，你说 湖大 的钟志华教授的 文章记录不怎么样，可真的是外行了。
  钟教授的 EI检索记录是不多，但是很多是 狠不错的。钟教授有好几篇文章发表在领域内顶级的杂志上，如Journal of Vibration and Shock等。值得注意的是，钟教授的文章在 自家的学报上发表的文章不多（《湖南大学学报》（自然科学版）是EI的）；即使是 国内的文章，耶绝大部分是在《中国机械工程学报》这样国内顶尖的刊物上）。另外，钟教授的很大一部分他本人不是第一作者的文章，第一作者都是他的学生。由此可见钟教授的 学术实力。
  钟老师的 SCI检索记录更好。他在90年代发表的好些文章已经奠定了他在领域内的地位。这可不是中南大学的 邱教授所能比的。

另外：建议借用你的湖大朋友的校园IP检索一下钟老师的完整记录后再说话。